Within the sixth page of its published ruling document concerning Chelsea's series of undisclosed transactions between 2011 and 2018, the Premier League outlines the factors it took into account when determining a punishment for the extended period of rule-breaking involving transfers.
The expressed requirement "to punish the club and to vindicate those clubs who have complied with the relevant rules" is cited. Accompanying this is "the necessity of deterring violations" and "the requirement to maintain public confidence in the integrity of the league."
However, has this objective been achieved?
The Premier League imposed a unprecedented £10m fine to Chelsea. A one-year transfer ban was deferred. Yet by avoiding a sporting sanction such as a points deduction, has the league failed to adequately punish one of English football's most serious cases of deception?
After all, the Premier League accepts that this matter involved "both clear and intentional breaches of the rules but... dishonesty and concealment in relation to monetary affairs". Moreover, that it "occurred with the knowledge and approval of certain senior former officers and/or board members."
Importantly, the misconduct had a material sporting impact, affecting on Chelsea but also some of their rivals.
The 36 payments amounting to over £47m over eight years involved the acquisitions of several of the key players in the club's recent history.
Players including Eden Hazard, Samuel Eto'o, Willian and David Luiz. Talents who helped Chelsea to become one of world football's top clubs throughout that era, when eight major trophies were secured.
And while there is no suggestion that these players were aware of the impropriety, it is of course conceivable that they could have all joined other clubs and aided those teams in securing those honours instead, were it not for the undisclosed payments from third-parties associated with former owner Roman Abramovich to unlicensed agents and other individuals.
The Signings Named in the Report:
- Ramires - £17m from Benfica in August 2010.
- David Luiz - £21.3m from Benfica in February 2011.
- Eden Hazard - £32m from Lille in June 2012.
- Andre Schurrle - £18m from Bayer Leverkusen in June 2013.
- Samuel Eto'o - free transfer from Anzhi Makhachkala in August 2013.
- Willian - £30m from Anzhi Makhachkala in August 2013.
- Nemanja Matic - £21m from Benfica in January 2014.
The Premier League says it applied leniency on the grounds that Chelsea's current ownership group self-reported violations that occurred under a former regime, and that the present leadership displayed "extraordinary" levels of co-operation. It has also clarified that the secret payments did not mean financial regulations capping losses would have been broken.
"We must recall that... this penalty is because of activities that took place under the former Chelsea regime," stated a senior regulatory official. "It's not the current owners or executive group."
For those former Chelsea executives who have subsequently left the game, that will be of minimal consequence. And certain competitor clubs surely feel that for a club with a squad valued at £1.5bn - the most expensively assembled in football history - a £10m fine is inadequate.
And while the present owners was not at all to blame for the misconduct, they have potentially benefited from the considerable success secured during the Abramovich era, which has only enhanced the value of their investment.
"Irksome" is how an ex- senior figure from a competitor characterized the Chelsea situation. Speaking on condition of anonymity, they asserted that their club "missed out on players, a key target in particular [in 2012], due to their actions."
They added: "I have sympathy for the new ownership point, but it's hardly a disincentive if you can divest before you get caught... an actual transfer ban would have been appropriate."
Trophies in the Period Covered:
- Premier League winners: 2014-15 and 2016-17.
- FA Cup winners: 2011-12, 2017-18.
- League Cup winners: 2014-15.
- Champions League winners: 2011-12.
- Europa League winners: 2012-13, 2018-19.
Separately, Chelsea were handed a nine-month-long youth transfer ban and a £750,000 fine over the registration of academy players between 2019 and 2022.
But contrast this ruling with those of Everton and Nottingham Forest in 2024, when both clubs received point penalties for PSR breaches that appear much less serious.
And what does it suggest about the efficacy of the Premier League's financial monitoring that it admits that without Chelsea's voluntary disclosures, a significant portion of the rule breaches may might not have been brought to its notice?
Therefore, what relevance, at all, does this precedent have on the Premier League's another major investigation?
Over a year after the end of an independent commission hearing into over 100 reported breaches of regulations by Manchester City, the club is continually waiting to learn its fate.
In contrast to Chelsea, City contest any misconduct and are fighting the allegations. And differently from the situation at Stamford Bridge, there has been no transition of proprietorship at the Etihad to provide extenuating circumstances.
But City fans will undoubtedly be heartened that the Premier League board did not appear to so much as consider a point penalty in the case of Chelsea, despite the "dishonesty and secrecy". In fact, it mentioned a two-window transfer ban as an "appropriate" punishment, if the club not come forward and assisted.
Earlier, in July 2023, European football's governing body fined the club £8m for the same matter. And the FA is anticipated to pursue similar action when it reveals the conclusion of its investigation into the affair in the near future.
But there are indications that Chelsea were apprehensive it could have been worse. In 2024, it was revealed that owners Todd Boehly and Behdad Eghbali set aside £150m of their acquisition cost for the club to account for potential fines from the Abramovich era. So far this chapter has cost the club about £18m.
A number of their competitors may feel the cost may have been higher in the shape of silverware and financial rewards they might have claimed. And also to the integrity and credibility of a league that depends on everyone abiding by the regulations.